23 Comments
User's avatar
Sylvia B's avatar

You didn't talk too much about “non-binary” men. I learned that it's a great way for a middle class white man in a seemingly hetero marriage to take himself down a step on the oppression totem pole, earning victimhood cred without having to do anything hard. If he's really trying, he might wear a pink shirt and paint his nails. Easy way to be a DEI hire. He can cry genocide if anyone ever dares to challenge him on anything.

Infamous Kitteh Mama's avatar

This is a terrific article, Sarah. Thank you.

Seth Schwartz's avatar

I met a 42 year old man a couple of weeks ago who insisted on being called “they” even though he looked just as male as any other man. He even had a beard! It’s just a way to get more oppression points without actually doing anything.

Sylvia B's avatar

Exactly. I've seen it so many times now.

Seth Schwartz's avatar

But nonbinary identities are on the decline … far fewer people are opting into these types of identities now than five years ago.

Sylvia B's avatar

It can't happen soon enough.

Seth Schwartz's avatar

The whole idea of “opting out“ of sex and gender is completely stupid. I don’t know who came up with that, but it’s totally silly.

Sylvia B's avatar

I can only imagine what they think of us silly “binary” folk who obviously adhere to every gender stereotype!

Seth Schwartz's avatar

People are seeing through this nonsense. You remember Sam Brinton, the Biden administration member who was bald with a goatee - along with a long, flowing dress? “They” would never be able to get away with that in public now. That movement has passed its sell-by date.

We would have been canceled 3 years ago just for having this conversation! Now we are laughing about it.

Goudou's avatar

Excellent article

BeadleBlog's avatar

I believe a good portion of these "nonbinary" fools, both male and female, are looking for attention. They want a label that they believe helps them stand out from the plebian masses, all without having to accomplish anything. Then there are the girls and women you described who use it as a way to separate from their femaleness. Speaking only of what I observe in the US, some are trapped in a cage of their own making. I'm 65 and had a career in the military, first in the USAR and later active USN. In basic training in 1979, there was a young woman who would get up 2 hours early just to start working on hair and makeup. Keep in mind that we were constantly out in the field daily and we didn't get much sleep as it was. She was exhausting herself for absolutely no reason. I gained much respect for her when she finally realized the ridiculousness of her obsession and threw all the maintenance in the garbage. She had likely grown up with a mother that enforced the face paint, as many girls did back in those days, followed in adulthood by face paint and hose required at work. Twenty years later on a navy carrier, with a ratio of 1/25 female/male, many of the young women were still performing the same maintenance rituals. I look around at all the radical cosmetic surgery today and accept that no matter how much we advance, some women, just like men, are going to make choices that don't help them. Part of the female gender myth is that we are the keepers of purity and therefor held on a "pedestal." My interpretation of the pedestal myth is men will be polite as long as one upholds the myth. But females are no "purer" than males, just usually less physically aggressive. As you stated, this ideology is a slap in the face to women in other countries where there's no choice.

Katharine's avatar

So much grist to the mill: thank you for this elucidating essay on the harms of this identity claim.

Short video from Amy Sousa to complement:

https://substack.com/@knownheretic/note/c-293294560?r=32ibef&utm_source=notes-share-action&utm_medium=web

Kingdom Civics's avatar

Excellent. Thank you for putting words to what I’ve struggled to pin down.

Frank's avatar

“smash patriarchy”? If there was a patriarchy, feminists would have to fight wars, and men would be exempt.

Sarah שרה's avatar

Oh, Frank, don’t worry…you’re safe. No one wants your kind of man fighting wars for anyone.

But I am glad to see that while you apparently haven’t mastered reading the feminist essays for which you keep signing up, you’re now able to at least pick out a couple words from an image 🤗